Skip to main content
Press Release

Megadeals, political instability and strong equity markets deliver M&A underperformance for insurers

The Willis Towers Watson Insurance M&A Performance Tracker shows that insurers undertaking M&A in 2016 underperformed non-acquisitive peers for the first time since 2010


October 2, 2017

The Willis Towers Watson Insurance M&A Performance Tracker shows insurers undertaking M&A in 2016 underperformed non-acquisitive peers for the first time since 2010

LONDON, Monday 2 October, 2017 —  For only the second time this decade, insurers undertaking an acquisition underperformed their sub-industry index, according to the Willis Towers Watson Insurance M&A Performance Tracker.

Key Findings

  • Insurance firms that carried out a significant acquisition in 2016 were likely to underperform their sub-industry index.
  • This is a reversal of the pattern of the previous eight years, when acquirers were likely to outperform their sub-industry index.
  • A high-value, low-volume M&A environment, political volatility and a strong equity market contributed to the weaker performance of acquisitive insurers in 2016.

The research, based on analysis of deals with a value of more than US$50m conducted in the insurance sector, showed that acquirers lagged the index by 6.4 percentage points in the period six months before announcement to the point six months after the deal closed. The last time acquirers underperformed their sub-index was in 2010.

"Although acquirers in the insurance sector haven't done as well in 2016 as they have in previous years, there are plausible explanations for this," said Fergal O'Shea, EMEA Life Insurance M&A Leader at Willis Towers Watson. "Since 2008, insurance acquirers have outperformed the market, a trend that has become even more pronounced since 2012. M&A is still beneficial and it will be interesting to see what the data for 2017 shows."

From 2008 onwards, insurers that carried out an acquisition outperformed peers by 3 percentage points. Since 2012, acquirers have traded 4.4 percentage points above their sub-industry index.

According to Willis Towers Watson, there are a number of factors that account for the recent underperformance. First, the general trend for high value and low volume in the M&A market. There were only 19 insurance deals tracked in 2016, and average deal value was almost double the average value in 2015. These figures mirror those from 2010, the last year in which acquisitive insurers underperformed.

“The market tends to be nervous around big, transformational transactions and more comfortable when most activity involves smaller incremental bolt-ons," says Brendan McMaster, Senior Consultant at Willis Towers Watson. "All other things being equal, big transactions are generally deemed to be riskier for the acquiring company.”

The drop in deal volumes could be attributed to a slowdown in activity in the life sector. The fall in Property & Casualty deals was less pronounced.

Strong equity markets may be another factor in the weaker performance of acquisitive insurers. "Equity markets are doing well, so firms don't need to do acquisitions as shareholders are rewarding those focusing on organic growth," said Fergal O'Shea.

Geopolitical uncertainty and the surprise poll results in the UK's Brexit referendum and US Presidential elections could also have been factors in shareholders' cautious reactions to big ticket transactions.

Separate Willis Towers Watson research tracking M&A across all sectors reveals similar trends to those in insurance, with acquirers underperforming firms that did not do deals. The consultancy suggests this could indicate that investors are in "risk-off" mode, especially when deal values have been higher than normal.

About the Insurance M&A Performace Tracker

Based on analysis from Willis Towers Watson and Cass Business School, the Tracker explores the performance of insurance companies that carry out major acquisitions against their sub-industry and regional indexes. Share price performance is measured as the percentage change in share price and is compared to MSCI Indices. The analysis is performance over two time periods:

  • From six months prior to the announcement date to one day post announcement
  • From six months prior to the announcement to six months after the deal closed.

Deal data is sourced from Thomson Reuters and only completed M&A deals with a value of at least $50m are included in this research.

About Insurance Consulting and Technology

Willis Towers Watson's Insurance Consulting and Technology business has over 1,200 colleagues operating in 35 markets worldwide. It is a leading provider of advice, solutions and software – primarily to the insurance industry. Its consulting services help clients manage risk and capital, improve business performance and create competitive advantage – by focusing on financial and regulatory reporting, enterprise risk and capital management, M&A and corporate restructuring, products, pricing, business management and strategy.

About Willis Towers Watson

Willis Towers Watson (NASDAQ: WLTW) is a leading global advisory, broking and solutions company that helps clients around the world turn risk into a path for growth. With roots dating to 1828, Willis Towers Watson has 40,000 employees serving more than 140 countries. We design and deliver solutions that manage risk, optimise benefits, cultivate talent, and expand the power of capital to protect and strengthen institutions and individuals. Our unique perspective allows us to see the critical intersections between talent, assets and ideas — the dynamic formula that drives business performance. Together, we unlock potential.

Related content tags, list of links Press Release United Kingdom
Contact Us